Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/Wilfred Benítez/archive1

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Wilfred Benitez[edit]

This was my first article ever. The article has definitely improved, as, when I wrote it I was a novel writer and POV. the photos are a plus, and the layout is pretty good in my opinion. I think people should also know about the downspirals many boxers live after being on top of the world; largely ignored by society that once held them high, they come to a crashing end after their career is over. Benitez exemplifies that. Antonio Americas Most wanted sex object Martin

  • Object: is missing several featured article criteria Joe D (t) 28 June 2005 21:16 (UTC)
  • Comment: This user now has three FAC nominations running concurrently. Be wary that all have major flaws, and will likely not get the attention they each so sorely need. Harro5 June 28, 2005 22:51 (UTC)
    • FYI, taken from above instructions: "Please do not place more than one nomination at a time — this makes it difficult to do each article and its objections justice." Flcelloguy | A note? | Desk 28 June 2005 23:37 (UTC)
  • Object: Should not be here, it is not featured article quality at all! Needs expansion, tidying, changed layout, references etc. Giano | talk 29 June 2005 12:07 (UTC)
  • Comment Take another look, although it still lacks comprehensiveness and references. Sfahey 30 June 2005 04:57 (UTC)
  • Excellent rescue job, improved layout etc. It is now a nice concise Wikipedia biography, even though it lacks references. Regarding becoming a FA it is too short and has insufficient detail about the man, what is he doing now for instance, I'm sure there is a lot more that could be said here. Sorry I still object. Giano | talk 30 June 2005 07:58 (UTC)
  • Neutral. This article is well-written, yet the person talked about is not famous enough. At least I've never heard of this guy. --Deryck C. 2005-06-30 15:31:58 (UTC)
I agree it is still not FA quality, but not having heard of someone is not a very good reason for objecting, especially if you consider "Soda can stove", "Exploding cows", and today's FA. FWIW, more millions of people have heard of Wilfred than many featured articles topics. "Neutral" was perhaps though an acceptable choice.Sfahey 1 July 2005 02:44 (UTC)
Thanks for being neutral as opposed to opposed, 9check out the redundancy there, hehe), but Benitez was the first, and because of boxing rules now, will forever be, the youngest guy ever to win a world title. He was the first Latino to be a three division world champion, the fifth boxer in boxing history overall, and the first in 40 years. He is a member of the International Boxing Hall of Fame and almost saw himself in the middle of an international problem when he became stranded in Argentina for one year. Ask on the internet who Wilfred Benitez or Wilfredo Gomez are, and you will get more than 2,000 pages of answer. Still, I appreciate that you didnt oppose. Thanks and God bless!! Antonio Let the Music Play Martin
  • Object. The two images on the page are both "copyrighted used with permission", which is an unacceptable license for Wikipedia. (Note that I'll be out of town until Tuesday, and probably won't be able to access Wikipedia until then) --Carnildo 1 July 2005 03:55 (UTC)
According to what I last read, wikipedia does allow photos copyrifghted by others, as long as we have been given permission. Antonio watch your skirts, ladies, I got a camera :) Martin
Only if that permission is compatible with the GFDL see [1]--nixie 16:24, 2 July 2005 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Featured_article_candidates/Wilfred_Benítez/archive1&oldid=1138475611"