Talk:Survivors (2008 TV series)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Introduction

Hello! I'm weebiloobil, and I'll be reviewing this article. Nice to see someone's already gone through to look for improvements :). If you want to contact me, don't feel free. Hopefully, we will all survive long enough to complete this review *cough*rubbish joke*cough*. The review should miracuously appear here within 7 days. Bye! - weebiloobil (talk) 17:26, 9 March 2009 (UTC)

Notes on a Scandal article

The article, at the moment, definitely seems Good Article quality. However, there are a few nitpicks that need to be adressed before I can promote the article:

• In the Anya charcter bit: "particularly Pat, her former lover" - who is Pat? Is this the Patricia enocuntered later in the article?

• In Episode 5: "the death of her lover, Jenny Collins" - there seems to be a bit of a debate over this. Could this be clarified, please?

• The Episode list contains 3 rhetorical questions, which just make it seem like a hyped-up magazine preview. They are:

"Can Tom prove himself to Samantha and what about the complication of his criminal past?" (episode 4)

"Is he as innocent as he seems or does he have more sinister intentions?" (episode 5)

"After these events, a young boy is handed a bag of belongings marked Peter Grant, and a horserider is shown looking for him. Is this Abby's son, Peter?" (episode 6)

• "A number of characters appeared irregularly during the series." - you only say one; not really "a number", is it?

I hope to see the article promoted; as such, I am placing the article on hold to see if any gnomes or fairies come along to address the issues here (I don't really expect gnomes to fix the article, just WikiGnomes and WikiFairies). See you in seven days! (or sooner if you contact me) - weebiloobil (talk) 22:19, 11 March 2009 (UTC)

Response and Actions Taken

Firstly, thanks very much for taking the time to review. I agree with all of your suggestions and have taken the following corrective action:

1. I changed the name to Patricia. This is, indeed the same character mentioned in the episode description.
2. I removed the reference to Jenny Collins being her lover. There is some debate you're correct and I don't believe personally that the episodes made this clear. Until someone finds a reliable source, it's probably best left out of the article.
3. I have either removed the movie trailer questions or reworded them into statements.
4. There's no reference that there are other characters who appeared throughout the series. There were, but I can't find any sources about them currently.

--Deadly∀ssassin 08:02, 12 March 2009 (UTC)

Brilliant! Have a Good Article :) - weebiloobil (talk) 20:24, 12 March 2009 (UTC)