Talk:Dream Theater/GA2

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Una Laguna^Talk 10:31, 18 September 2010 (UTC)

I'm quick-failing this article because it features numerous issues which I seriously doubt can be adequately dealt with in a week:

• This article features a {{Refimprove}} tag, making it an immediate quick-fail.
• There are many unsourced paragraphs throughout the article, and what looks like some original research in the Live performances section.
• There is no Musical style section, describing the genre of music this band plays. This is essential for an article on a band.
• Violation of Fair Use on the first two pictures in the History section.
• Various stylistic issues: citations aren't properly formatted (see WP:CITE#HOW), and there are many one- and two-sentence paragraphs.

Other things to note:

• In future, please check articles you plan to nominate for Good Article against the Good Article Criteria to ensure there are no major flaws in the article.
• This article was listed as a "Miscellaneous" GAN; it should have been listed under "Music".
• For general comments on improving articles, please use Peer Review in the future.