File:Dateline Danger! 03-16-1969.jpg

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dateline_Danger!_03-16-1969.jpg(750 × 500 pixels, file size: 97 KB, MIME type: image/jpeg)

Summary[edit]

Non-free media information and use rationale true for Al McWilliams
Description

Original black-and-white art for Sunday color comic strip

Source

http://d1g4sq00ps2bp3.cloudfront.net/images/9181.jpg

Article

Al McWilliams

Portion used

Single example from a 1968-1974 defunct comic strip showing the first African-American starring character of a comic strips

Low resolution?

Low and greatly reduced, unsuitable to use for high quality reproduction.

Following discussion with an admin, who advised me on Feb. 3, 2015 to more fully explain the rationale for the current size so that it would be acceptable under image guidelines: This 750px image appears at a much-reduced 400px on the article pages; it is at a larger size here because, when attempting to reduce it from the original upload's size (500px), the resultant 400px image became muddy and unreadable. It is still far from high-resolution, and at the current size the content is barely legible but legible enough to serve its encyclopedic purpose.

Additionally, it is a Sunday strip, so cropping it would be like only showing part of a magazine cover or a movie poster. There are extremely few daily strips of this obscure comic online, and in the handful I could find, the African-American is tied up or being beaten — neither of which conveys his historic place as the first black hero of a comic strip. Showing him being victimized rather than heroic in this context also could be construed as a mildly racist commentary.

Purpose of use

To identify the characters and art style of this historically significant comic strip containing the first African-American starring character in a comic strip, as detailed in the encyclopedia article about the series' artist co-creator

Replaceable?

Irreplaceable

Other information

The image is covered by fair use because: It is a low-resolution, greatly reduced image unsuitable for high-end reproduction; The use of the image will not affect the value of the original work or limit any copyright holder's rights or ability to sell or distribute the original work; The image is used as the sole means of visual identification of the article subject's most significant and historically important work; This image is not used in misleading manner; It is at the approximate minimum size for the character of Danny Raven, the first African-American starring character in a comic strip, to be visually "read" and to have his dialog be readable.

Fair useFair use of copyrighted material in the context of Al McWilliams//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Dateline_Danger!_03-16-1969.jpgtrue
Non-free media information and use rationale true for Dateline: Danger!
Description

Original black-and-white art for Sunday color comic strip

Source

http://d1g4sq00ps2bp3.cloudfront.net/images/9181.jpg

Article

Dateline: Danger!

Portion used

Single example from a 1968-1974 defunct comic strip showing the first African-American starring character of a comic strips

Low resolution?

Low and greatly reduced, unsuitable to use for high quality reproduction.

Following discussion with an admin, who advised me on Feb. 3, 2015 to more fully explain the rationale for the current size so that it would be acceptable under image guidelines: This 750px image appears at a much-reduced 400px on the article pages; it is at a larger size here because, when attempting to reduce it from the original upload's size (500px), the resultant 400px image became muddy and unreadable. It is still far from high-resolution, and at the current size the content is barely legible but legible enough to serve its encyclopedic purpose.

Additionally, it is a Sunday strip, so cropping it would be like only showing part of a magazine cover or a movie poster. There are extremely few daily strips of this obscure comic online, and in the handful I could find, the African-American is tied up or being beaten — neither of which conveys his historic place as the first black hero of a comic strip. Showing him being victimized rather than heroic in this context also could be construed as a mildly racist commentary.

Purpose of use

To identify the characters and art style of this historically significant comic strip containing the first African-American starring character in a comic strip, as detailed in the encyclopedia article about the series

Replaceable?

Irreplaceable

Other information

The image is covered by fair use because: It is a low-resolution, greatly reduced image unsuitable for high-end reproduction; The use of the image will not affect the value of the original work or limit any copyright holder's rights or ability to sell or distribute the original work; The image is used as the sole means of visual identification of the article subject, a significant and historically important work This image is not used in misleading manner; It is at the approximate minimum size for the character of Danny Raven, the first African-American starring character in a comic strip, to be visually "read" and to have his dialog be readable.

Fair useFair use of copyrighted material in the context of Dateline: Danger!//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Dateline_Danger!_03-16-1969.jpgtrue

Licensing:[edit]

File history

Click on a date/time to view the file as it appeared at that time.

Date/TimeThumbnailDimensionsUserComment
current01:18, 14 April 2014Thumbnail for version as of 01:18, 14 April 2014750 × 500 (97 KB)Tenebrae (talk | contribs)Adjusted to change the yellow aging of the paper closer to its original black-and-white line art. Made image a little sharper.
03:37, 13 April 2014No thumbnail750 × 500 (81 KB)Tenebrae (talk | contribs)Previous version was so small it was unreadable, which negated the primary reason for the use of this art: visual identification of the historically significant first African-American starring character in a comic strip.
03:34, 13 April 2014No thumbnail500 × 333 (42 KB)Tenebrae (talk | contribs)== Summary == {{Non-free 2D art|image has rationale=yes}} {{Non-free use rationale |Article=Al McWilliams |Description=Original black-and-white art for Sunday color comic strip |Source=http://d1g4sq00ps2bp3.cloudfront.net/images/9181.jpg |Portion=Singl...
The following pages on the English Wikipedia use this file (pages on other projects are not listed):

Metadata